In This Edition

Governor gets close view of Ely State Prison

Rodders announce winners of annual car show

Shhh! Don't tell anyone UNLV was you know where

As We See It

This Week's Cartoon
Thumbnail
About Us
As We See It
Reid's staff needs to improve
Harry Reid's Nevada staff needs to do a better job of keeping the Senate Majority Leader abreast of what's happening all over his home state.


Reid's made a few gaffs the past few weeks in explaining his vision for Nevada to lead the nation in developing alternative sources of energy to fossil fuels.

On Aug. 8, in an opinion piece by the senator, published on Page 1 of the Ely Times, the Man from Searchlight informed us that Sierra Pacific Resources was lying to us that our power rates would be lower if the Ely Energy Center were built.

Too bad none of his staff told him we don't get our power from Sierra Pacific or Nevada Power.

Our power comes from the Deseret Power Cooperative, which gets some power from Glen Canyon Dam and the Bonanza coal plant in Utah.

The senator also complained about the hidden medical costs as children and the elderly are forced to breath the fumes generated by burning coal. He says a “cleaner” coal plant is still dirty.

But didn't his staff tell him that the plants are being located far enough up Steptoe Valley, that no population centers will be downwind.

Sen. Reid also notes that White Pine County can benefit from developing geothermal energy sources near Cherry Creek and Butte Valley.

That's comforting. But the BLM held an auction on Aug. 14 for geothermal parcels in California and Nevada. There was high interest as nearly $20 million was bid for six parcels in California and 43 in Nevada.

The high bid -- a record high -- of $14,000 per acre went for a California parcel; the second high bid of $11,000 per acre went for a second California parcel. Top bid for a Nevada parcel was $510 per acre. The lowest successful bids were $300 per acre.

The BLM received nearly $11.7 million for the Nevada parcels in Washoe, Churchill, Mineral, Pershing, Nye, Humboldt and Lander County.

No parcels in White Pine were auctioned, so we're not sure if any energy companies want to site a geothermal plant in the county.

The senator has made some other recent mistakes, based on information provided by his staff.

At a recent meeting in Pahrump, Reid said California is getting only one percent of its power from coal sources, according to a report in our sister newspaper The Pahrump Valley Times.

But according to California, 15.7 percent of its power is coming from coal. Here's a link to the California Energy Commission website: (http://www.energy.ca.gov/electricity/gross_system_power.html. By the way, California has nuclear power plants, as well.

Reid told the Clean Energy Summit he hosted last weekend that if Sierra Pacific Resources was seeking a transitional power source while more green power is developed, it should build more natural gas-fired power plants.

Again, Reid's staff hasn't been keeping up with what's going on in Nevada.

An Aug. 9 report in the Las Vegas Review-Journal expressed the concern of the Nevada Public Utilities Commission that Nevada will run short of the expensive, but clean-burning fuel within three years if new gas fields aren't developed and more pipelines built.

Natural gas doesn't seem to be much of a solution, at least not in the short term.

The senator was scheduled to meet in Ely this morning with members of the Great Basin National Park Foundation, the county and the city. The 9 a.m. meeting at the Prospector Inn was by invitation only.

The Ely Times learned of the meeting only after we were contacted by other private citizens who had learned of it. But once Reid's office was contacted, we were allowed to send a reporter. That story will run next week.

We hope we won't just be repeating the senator's new mantra that “coal is dirty and cleaner coal is still dirty.” As the senator speaks with more Nevadans about his proposal, we hope he comes to understand that green power will take time to develop and replace fossil fuels.

We suggest the senator considers a national plan, since his position with the Senate would merit that course of action. Power needs are growing, not just in Nevada, but nationwide.

We suggest he gets legislation introduced to cap carbon dioxide emissions from coal-fired plants at present-day levels. Older, more-polluting plants need to be replaced.

As new plants come online, the older plants can be shut down -- maintaining current levels of CO2 emission. The first objective of green-power development should be to cover the projected increase in power usage -- which in itself will be a challenge.

As alternative energy sources are developed beyond that level, fossil fuel plants can be replaced megawatt for megawatt by green power.

The senator isn't famous for modifying his viewpoint. But that may have to do with the quality of information he gets from his staff.

Leave Your Comment 11 comment(s)
Terms & Conditions
The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. The Ely Times does not review comments before publication nor guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the web editor.
Sorry, comments have been closed.

realist wrote on Aug 27, 2007 9:03 AM:

" Delaine, you'll learn the folly of using your own name on websites. The court system is full of victims who have been targeted resulting from their Internet comments. It's commendable you are willing to stand up for your beliefs. But you must protect yourself from the less-than-sane denizens of cyberspace. Utilize a user name. "

Delaine Spilsbury wrote on Aug 26, 2007 10:08 AM:

" People who don't sign their comments don't deserve to be read. What are they hiding? "

Sam wrote on Aug 25, 2007 7:37 PM:

" That's exactly right, Native, you hit it the nail right on the head. "

native white piner wrote on Aug 25, 2007 6:55 PM:

" Seems to me, we have accepted projects in the past eg: the prison, that on the surface looked appealing to White Pine coffers, but in reality have created financial and security burdens down the road. I for one think the benefits aren't worth the costs. Why would White Pine want to take bait of one ecological dissaster while fighting another? I don't condone water or power for Clark County at our expense. "

D. from Vegas wrote on Aug 24, 2007 11:11 PM:

" Far enough up Steptoe Valley for what? you think the fumes will be negligible? Apparantly you have not traveled to the site of the proposed construction. This plant will ruin many beautiful recreational areas in the Humbolt Nat. Forest. The clean, unmolested outdoors is what makes this area so appealing. Why don't we just ruin it in the name of the almighty dollar?? Not on my watch. "

Chig wrote on Aug 24, 2007 10:43 PM:

" I understand that there will be costs associated with everything. But I lived around coal plants, 30 year old plants that did not pollute like people say and there was no increased sickness among people. I know that they were not perfectly clean but they were clean plants 30 years ago, so I will bet the new ones will be that much cleaner. There were blue skies and green mountains and deer and all other forms of wildlife around them. We need an increased tax base and Harry cannot give that to us in 3 years. These plants will not destroy our community. They will help us survive. "

Sam wrote on Aug 24, 2007 6:46 PM:

" Politics aside, I really think Reid has it right. Looking at the long term trends and thinking about the future is hard but necessary when you're talking about building coal plants that pollute locally and regionally. The fact is, we are gluttonous consumers of energy...we like it cheap, we use a lot, and damn it we're entitled to as much as we need whenever we need it. Well, guess what people? The bill is coming due and it's a whopper. We will NEVER get out of this energy crisis until we all understand and adapt to the true cost of energy; that means conserving it, that means paying for it, that means tallying the true environmental and financial impacts of how we make it. Nothing comes from nothing. "

Chig wrote on Aug 24, 2007 4:09 PM:

" You are right. We need to conserve. Everyone needs to. But are we? What have any of us shut off in the last week. I will bet nothing. Our society will not shut off or conserve electricity. I too agree with Harry about alternative power. And I don't trust him at all. His idea is a good one. I just have one question for him. Will the windmills, and geothermal, and solar power be ready in 3 or 4 short years when the demand is there? I don't think so. Build the plants close some old ones and in 25 years when the green powere is available for all to use shut them down. In the meantime we can have some money in our county coffers and a new middle school and roads without holes and a few sidewalks would be a novel idea. Hang in there Harry I can hardly wait to vote you out in the next election! Who knows after you are beaten you can become a staffer for Ted Kennedy. Oh wait you already are! "

Reid still has it right wrote on Aug 24, 2007 2:50 PM:

" No, power doesn't need growing nationwide. Power needs conserving - we need to use less. We don't need to cap CO2 and keep it at the same level - we need to reduce it. The pollution will not always blow away from Ely - the wind changes all the time. And it really doesn't matter which way the wind blows - the toxins will find their way into our air, soil, and water. It's all connected. And the quality of information received is always relative, as all sorts of twisted facts get tossed around in this debate. Overall, Reid still has the right - and the good - idea. "

BLM friend wrote on Aug 23, 2007 11:19 AM:

" Geothermal lease parcels are nominated for auction. No White Pine sites have been nominated and so none were included in the auction. "

GolferDude wrote on Aug 23, 2007 9:43 AM:

" Thanks Harpoon for putting a spotlight on the King of Gaffs. How can Dirty Harry tell us that we should turn to geothermal if we don't have any hot water here? I'm sick of him playing politics with us. I think WE should decide if WE want a coal plant or two here or not. Reid should stay in Washington and mess things up there, not here. I was at the Ely Energy Center reception a couple of weeks ago and asked what I could do to help. I was told writing letters could help. I for one am going to write a letter or send an EMAIL in support of the Ely Energy Center. Anybody know where White Pine Energy's office is? Here is the email Doris_Metcalf@blm.gov and here's their address: Doris Metcalf BLM Ely Field Office HC 33, BOx 33500 Ely, NV 89301 "